MKUltra, Anti-Science, and Mind Control

MKUltra (pronouced M-K-ultra) was a covert Central Intelligence Agency research program carried out between 1953 and 1973 to investigate mind control. It used techniques such as high doses of the psychedelic drug LSD, hypnosis, sensory isolation, and electroshock therapy to influence a subject’s brain, and in particular to obtain secrets from unwilling people. This program is notorious for torturing studying subjects without their consent, which is considered a grave sin in research today.

One subproject of MKUltra (#119) was to use very low frequency electromagnetic fields to influence the brain. This project comes disturbingly close to techniques I’ve worked on over the years, such as transcranial magnetic stimulation. It got me to wondering: is mind control using electromagnetic fields possible?

The Foundation Trilogy,
by Issac Asimov.

I guess I have thought about this before, because in the August 14, 2015 post in this blog I suggested that the “psychic probe” described in Isaac Asimov’s famous Foundation Trilogy might be made by combining transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and magnetoencephalography (MEG), which are both described in Chapter 8 of Intermediate Physics for Medicine and Biology. In that post I wrote “a combo TMS/MEG unit could therefore both detect and alter brain function.” Of course, I was writing tongue-in-cheek, joking about how a science fiction device might have worked within the constraints of real science. On the other hand, perhaps I was actually an MKUltra agent sending a secret message to my underground accomplices?

That last sentence mocks the recent conspiracy theories surrounding MKUltra. Last week the House Task Force on the Declassification of Federal Secrets held a hearing about the research program. It didn’t focus on the historical record (which is sparse because most of the MKUltra documents were destroyed) but instead went off on weird tangents, talking about things like mind control related to the assassination of President Kennedy. The purpose of this hearing seemed to be aimed primarily at blaming science in general for past errors. Some issues that were brought up, like MKUltra itself, were serious mistakes that should be, and have been, investigated. Others, like bogus lab leak theories related to the origin of Covid, were just crazy talk with no scientific justification. One researcher, Elizabeth Ginexi, a respected former program official at the National Institutes of Health, was invited by the Democrats to talk about the horrendous anti-science policies currently imposed on NIH by anti-vax zealot Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. Ginexi (a hero in my view) tried to discuss these vital issues, but was constantly cut off by Republican members of the committee who were focused on the bizarre and engaged in an attempt to demonize scientists and public health workers.

But back to my question: could electromagnetic fields be used for brain control? Well, transcranial magnetic stimulation is currently used to treat depression, so you can’t rule out the possibility. However, the technique is very nonspecific. I spent seven years at NIH trying to improve the focality and spatial resolution of transcranial magnetic stimulation. Generating a localized stimulus is extraordinarily difficult, especially for activating deep brain structures. You can use transcranial magnetic stimulation to make individual fingers move, but only because the hand has a widespread representation in the motor cortex. The idea that transcranial magnetic stimulation could control individual thoughts or suggest specific actions seems like science fiction to me. Other techniques that have been suggested as potentially useful for mind control are brain-computer interfaces and deep brain stimulation. Both of these have important medical uses. For example, deep brain stimulation can help reduce or control tremors caused by Parkinson’s disease. Perhaps these techniques could potentially be used for controlling behavior, but they are highly invasive (requiring surgery to implant electrodes in the brain).

Are Electromagnetic Fields 
Making Me Ill?

What about techniques growing out of subproject 119? That work was led by W. Ross Adey and Mary (“Mollie”) Brazier, two leading scientists studying how electromagnetic fields interact with, and are produced by, the brain. I mentioned Adey in my book Are Electromagnetic Fields Making Me Ill?. He claimed to find “window” effects, for which one particular applied field strength resulted in an observable effect, but stronger or weaker fields did not. Similarly, he found that certain frequencies had marked responses (“resonances”) but both higher and lower frequencies did not. These window effects are not very reproducible and are not widely accepted today. Generally, resonant effects are claimed at very low frequencies (say, 20 Hz). Ultimately subproject 119 ended in failure because no mind control methods were found. Some say that a modern offshoot of this research is microwave weapons responsible for the Havana syndrome. Again, in Are Electromagnetic Fields Making Me Ill? I discuss why electromagnetic fields are almost certainly not responsible for the Havana syndrome. My opinion is that this is another anti-science conspiracy theory.

The final question I address is: could something like MKUltra happen today? The ethics rules governing research are far more stringent now than several decades ago. About 15 years ago, I served for one year in an interim role as Oakland University’s Vice Provost for Research, which is the chief research officer at the institution. Among other things, I was in charge of overseeing research misconduct issues at OU. Any human subjects research had to go through our Institutional Review Board. If a faculty member merely wanted to give a simple survey to students, that survey had to be assessed by this board and a detailed consent form was required. Any potentially dangerous human studies were monitored particularly closely, and informed consent was essential. It’s the same at all academic institutions. MKUltra would be virtually impossible in today’s academic research environment. Could it happen in the CIA or another research center associated with the military? I don’t know. Perhaps. But the CIA and other intelligence agencies can’t compete with academia and scientific institutions like the NIH and NSF when it comes to scientific advances. (Take, for example, the recent brouhaha over the military’s claims about “ghost murmur” which are almost certainly bogus.) I don’t believe MKUltra or anything related to it is going on today, especially involving electromagnetic fields to control the brain. I believe that such a suggestion is a conspiracy theory, advanced to discredit scientists and scientific institutions. It’s part of the Republican War on Science. Please, don’t believe the anti-science crackpots. At the very least, insist that they support their claims with evidence. They rarely can.

Angela Rasmussen and Liz Ginexi discuss MKUltra and What Really Happened in the Wuhan Lab

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yrf0i9O3iRE